Vce psychology craik and lockharts levels of processing. On the asymmetric effects of mindwandering on levels of. Canadian journal of psychology outstanding contributions series. Lockhart in 1972, describes memory recall of stimuli as a function of the depth of mental processing. Craik and lockhart levels processing vce u3 psychology duration. For example, it is well established that conceptual semantic processing at encoding leads to. Dec 02, 2019 this resource covers shallow and deeper processing, expanding into advantages and disadvantages including relevant sporting examples. Deeper levels of analysis produce more elaborate, longerlasting, and stronger memory traces than shallow levels of analysis. Differential involvement of frontotemporal networks nathan s. The deeper the level of processing, the easier the information is to recall. These results are replicated in craik and lockhart. This theory came about after the criticism of the aforementioned multistore model, which focused on the structures involved in the stm and the ltm. Second, craik and lockhart assumed that the deeper the level of processing, the more durable the resulting memory.
Deep processing led to superior recognition memory, independent of test expectancy. The levels of processing framework proposed by craik and lockhart 1972 presented a general approach to memory research that has been widely influential and the subject of intensive critical scrutiny. Lowlevel processing focuses on external characteristics of a word or. How your working memory makes sense of the world duration. Lockhart, craik levels of processing commentary 1990. Craik and lockhart 1972 stated that in the encoding stage there is a series of processing hierarchies. A framework for memory research 1972 journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior. One of the main arguments criticising this theory is the fact that the degree of processing being used by a subject in an experiment cannot be determined. Levels of processing model of memory edexcel psychology. Memory performance would vary systematically with the depth of processing. Buchsbaum2 abstract how does the brain maintain toberemembered informa tion in working memory wm, particularly when the focus of. Their conceptual framework has the advantage of directing attention to mental events and processes, but there are several difficulties. That is, one characteristic of ltm is that it is highly sensitive to the qualitative depth with which memory items are processed when they are initially encoded.
To test lop measure durability of memory trace to measure which information is recalled best semantic, structural or phonetic procedure. Although the theory has a lot of supportive evidence from experiments there is no independent measure of whether processing was deep or shallow. A levelsofprocessing model has generally been used to interpret these fmdings. Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior 11, 671684 1972 levels of processing. Some current data and arguments are reexamined in the light of this alternative framework and implications for further research considered. In the next section i discuss whether memory can be regarded as pure processing, the role of shortterm memory in an lop framework, measurement of depth in lop, encodingretrieval interactions, the concept of consolidation. Levels of processing model craik and lockhart flashcards.
An alternative framework for human memory research is then outlined in terms of depth or levels of processing. In this article i first briefly survey some enduring legacies of the craik and lockhart 1972 article on levels of processing lop and address some common criticisms. Nevertheless, there have been criticisms of craik and lockharts theory on levels of processing. More memory levels of processing model craik and lockhart 1972 storage varies along a continuous dimension in terms of depth of coding there are an infinite number of levels the level at which information is stored will depend on how it is encoded deeper processing will lead to better recall rehearsal can have two functions. A shallow level of processing could be focusing on how a word sounds. The present study examined levels of processing by manipulating the encoding of words at study in a physical, rhyming, and semantic condition. Jul 07, 2015 craik and lockhart levels processing vce u3 psychology duration. The basic notions are that the episodic memory trace may be thought of as a rather automatic byproduct of operations carried out by the cognitive system and that the durability of the trace is a positive. My reactions to this ex cathedra statement are mixed. We consider the history of processing approaches to cognition, and suggest that the levelsofprocessing approach helped to change the zeitgeist in the 1970s and succeeding decades.
The researches done by hyde and jenkins 1973 and craik and tulving 1975 also prove the same results. The levels of processing model, created by fergus i. An example of different levels of processing would be when trying to remember someones name. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
In addition, they claim that understanding is at present preferable to prediction. Ten experiments were designed to explore the levels of processing framework for human memory research proposed by craik and lockhart 1972. Users may have to be alert to deviations of process indicators from normal operation digital or analog. As a consequence, two tasks requiring deep processing are compared. One possible description of this relationship is that levels of processing has its effect by influencing the likelihood that the processing will prove to be transferappropriate. Unlike the multistore model it is a nonstructured approach.
Levels of processing, transferappropriate processing, and. Depth of processing and the retention of words in episodic. It suggests that it is depth of processing that leads to stronger memories, rather than there being separate memory stores. Levels of processing psychology bibliographies cite. Levels of processing the levels of processing theory suggests that memory is based on the depth of procedures used during intake of information. Levels of processing psychology bibliographies cite this. Stimuli that are attended to, fully analyzed, and enriched by associations or images yield a deeper encoding of the event, and a longlasting trace. Lockhart in 1972, refers to three levels of encoding any information. Start studying levels of processing model craik and lockhart. This resource covers shallow and deeper processing, expanding into advantages and disadvantages including relevant sporting examples.
More memory levels of processing model craik and lockhart. Craik and tulvings research supports their level of processing theory. The levels of processing effect, identified by fergus i. In the next section i discuss whether memory can be regarded as pure processing, the role of shortterm memory in an lop framework, measurement of depth in lop, encodingretrieval interactions, the concept of. The levels of processing framework proposed by fergus i. Similarities and differences between working memory and. The levels of processing model of memory craik and lockhart the levels of processing model of memory was proposed by craik and lockhart.
Alevel pe, ocr, craik and lockharts level of processing. The levels of processing model craik and lockhart, 1972 focuses on the depth of processing involved in memory, and predicts the deeper information is processed, the longer a memory trace will last. In 1972, craik and lockhart developed the concept of levels of processing. Lockhart in 1972, describes memory recall of stimuli as a function of the depth of. Traditional theories of memory segmented human memory into different stores for example, the multistore model with sensory, shortterm and longterm stores. Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior, 11, 67l84. On the other hand, according to a levelofprocessing account craik and lockhart, 1972 the task requires deep processing. In this article we outline some of the main ideas and observations embodied in the levels of processing approach to memory research craik and lockhart, 1972. Since there has been some ambiguity in the usage of terms in this area, we shall follow the convention of using stm. Third, the levels of processing view assumes that rehearsal can be relatively unimportant. During the shallower processing level perceptual processing, the subject initially perceives the physical and sensory characteristics of the stimulus. A lot of rehearsal using a shallow level of processing will lead to worse memory than much less rehearsal using a deep level of processing.
The behavioral consequences of offtask thought mindwandering on primarytask performance are now well documented across an increasing range of tasks. According to the levels of processing framework, stimulus information is processed at multiple levels simultaneously depending upon its characteristics. In each case, half of the subjects were informed that there would be a subsequent test, while half were not so informed. The levels of processing effect was the creation of robert s. The purpose of the present article is to offer some retrospective observations on the ideas associated with levels of processing. Ccnumber 50 this weeks citation classicdecember 10. To determine the level of processing between semantic and phonemic encoding, 26 word pairs was shown to 837 undergraduates and each participant has 30 seconds to determine whether it was a category association or rhyming relationship. This theory by craik and lockhart suggests that memory doesnt have separate levels of storage, unlike the multi store model. Depth of processing and the retention of words in episodic memory. To determine the level of processing between semantic and phonemic encoding, 26 word pairs was shown to 837 undergraduates and each participant has 30 seconds to determine whether it was a. Craik and lockhart 1972 proposed that it is the method and depth of processing affects how an experience is stored in memory, rather than rehearsal.
According to the web of science, since the publication of craik and lockhart almost 40 years ago, 3,500 articles have cited the original article accessed july 2011. Craik and tulving also found in one of the experiments that when the subjects new the purpose of the study, results still remained consistent. As deeper processing would logically take more time to execute than shallow processing e. The duo introduced this model as an alternative to prior. Canadian journal of psychology outstanding contributions. More memory levels of processing model craik and lockhart 1972. University of toronto, toronto, ontario, canada in the 1960s, human memory was thought about principally in terms of stores that were characterized as holding. Levels of processing consider that there are an unknown number of stores of processing levels of memory being stored in different forms of information.
960 1140 1224 1588 956 245 1312 1079 133 381 647 21 1290 1500 719 1235 894 601 954 749 287 360 315 305 1337 949 799 925 786 885 1147 1077 630 1452 496